The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel

Fire Island Pines, United States View on map
9.5 Exceptional Based on 15 reviews
Editor's Pick

"A heated pool sits near the beach, complemented by provided chairs and umbrellas. Beach towels wait by the outdoor shower. Best for weekend couples, less so for anyone needing consistent service."

From US$ 402 US$ 341 per night
Save 15%
Check-in
27 Sept 2026
Check-out
28 Sept 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
  • Free cancellation
    on many rooms
  • No booking fees
    Pay at the hotel
  • Secure booking
    Your data is safe
  • Best price guarantee
    Found a better price?

Why guests choose The Madison Fire Island Pines

  • Heated Pool
    87°F year-round
  • Beach Access
    2-min walk
  • Massage Services
    In-house therapist
  • Continental Breakfast
    Bagels & eggs
  • Social Atmosphere
    Communal living areas
  • Pet Policy
    Dogs welcome

Overview

Located a mere 5 minutes' walk from Pavilion, the elegant The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel includes a swimming pool and a sun terrace. The guest house features Wi-Fi throughout the property and 8 rooms that offer views of the garden.

Such city attractions as Barrett Beach Park, which is not far from the Fire Island Pines hotel, and Fire Island National Seashore, which is merely 0.7 miles away, are well worth a visit. Within a 60-minute drive of the 3-star The Madison Fire Island Pines Hotel, guests can visit West New York. Cultural experiences in the area feature Long Island Maritime Museum, situated about 15 minutes' drive from this accommodation.

Providing a separate toilet, some bathrooms are also equipped with a hairdryer and bath sheets.

A continental breakfast is available every morning. Serving a wide assortment of dishes, Canteen is a stone's throw from the Madison.

  • Check-in
    from 15:30 until 21:00
  • Check-out
    until 12:00
  • Hotel class
    3 stars
The Madison Fire Island Pines
Our tips

Should you book The Madison Fire Island Pines?

Perfect if you
  • Want a pet-friendly stay - pets are allowed at the guest house.
  • Need to be close to nightlife - the hotel is a 5-minute walk from Pavilion.
  • Prefer a small, intimate guest house with only 9 rooms.
Maybe skip if you
  • Expect daily room cleaning - it's not part of the standard service at this property.
Best for
  • A heated pool maintained at 87 degrees for year-round swimming
  • A rooftop deck offering views of Fire Island

Facilities of The Madison

General
  • No smoking on site
  • Parking
  • Pets allowed
  • Adults only
Leisure & Sports
  • Heated swimming pool
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Beach umbrellas
  • Sun loungers
  • Sun terrace
  • Garden area
Room Amenities
  • Free Wi-Fi in rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Terrace

Policies

The Madison Fire Island Pines applies these conditions to all bookings.
Check-in / Check-out
Check-in
from 15:30 until 21:00
Check-out
until 12:00
Important info
  • Children and extra beds
  • There are no extra beds provided in a room.

Thank you for your feedback

Thank you for subscribing

Close
Check-in
27 Sept 2026
Check-out
28 Sept 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
Select the dates
to see the actual offers